top of page

Unveiling the True Expense: How a $135 Million Verdict Highlights Erosion Control Compliance

Updated: Jun 27, 2023

A recent news story involving a Tennessee solar company and its contractor, Silicon Ranch Corp. (SRC) and IEA Inc., sheds light on the repercussions of disregarding proper erosion and sediment control measures. Following a legal battle, a U.S. District Court jury awarded a staggering $135.5 million to a couple in Stewart County whose property suffered extensive damage due to the defendants' actions. This case serves as a vivid demonstration of why adhering strictly to erosion and sediment control regulations is absolutely crucial. In this blog post, we will explore the significance of maintaining erosion control standards and utilize this news report to highlights the adverse effects that arise when such standards are neglected.

Solar Panel Farm

stock image form

The Devastating Effects of Inadequate Erosion Control Compliance:

The trial revolved around the Lumpkin solar facility in Stewart County, Georgia, developed by Silicon Ranch Corp. and constructed by IEA Inc. Both entities undertook clearing and mass grading on approximately 1,000 acres without implementing sufficient erosion and sediment control measures. Consequently, the plaintiffs, Shaun and Amie Harris, suffered substantial damage to their property.

“For two years SRC and IEA failed to stabilize and vegetate almost a thousand acres they had mass graded – which was breaking the law.”, thereby making them liable for the consequences of their negligence. The compensatory damages verdict delivered by the jury amounted to $10.5 million. However, it was during the punitive phase that the true magnitude of the defendants' actions was revealed. The jury concluded that Silicon Ranch Corp., IEA Inc., and IEA's subsidiary, IEA Constructors, LLC, acted deliberately with the intent to cause harm. Consequently, punitive damages of $25 million were imposed on SRC, while IEA Inc. and IEA Constructors, LLC each faced punitive damages of $50 million.

image from

Lessons Learned - The Importance of staying compliant:

This case stands as a cautionary tale not only for the renewable energy industry but for any sector involved in land development. It underscores the significance of prioritizing adherence to erosion and sediment control measures right from the project's inception. Neglecting erosion control compliance not only exposes companies to substantial financial repercussions but also jeopardizes the environment and neighboring communities.

Maintaining erosion and sediment control standards involves the implementation of effective strategies to prevent soil erosion, sedimentation, and runoff during construction activities. These measures safeguard water quality, preserve soil health, and protect neighboring properties from harm. Adherence generally entails actions such as deploying sediment barriers, constructing retaining walls, employing erosion control blankets, and implementing comprehensive revegetation plans.

The significant financial burden faced by Silicon Ranch Corp. and IEA Inc. should serve as a wake-up call for organizations and individuals engaged in similar projects. Neglecting to implement proper erosion and sediment control measures can lead to severe legal consequences, tarnish reputations, and result in substantial financial losses. The $135.5 million verdict in this case is certain to leave an indelible impact on the defendants' future operations.

Furthermore, non-adherence to erosion and sediment control regulations can have far-reaching environmental consequences. Soil erosion causes the loss of fertile topsoil, resulting in diminished agricultural productivity, increased sedimentation in water bodies, and damage to aquatic ecosystems. Runoff laden with sediment degrades water quality, negatively impacting aquatic life and compromising the availability of clean drinking water.


The recent legal battle and the subsequent $135.5 million verdict against Silicon Ranch Corp. and its contractor, IEA Inc., serves as a stark reminder of the utmost importance of adhering to erosion control measures. This case underscores the dire need for all industries involved in land development to prioritize the implementation of effective erosion and sediment control measures. Ad


bottom of page